Dedicated to Emily Dunn, killed by the F-Market Line in the Castro

Young Woman Killed by Muni Driver Remembered in the Castro

Photos of Emily Dunn have been posted at the intersection where she was killed Friday. Photos: Bryan Goebel

Excerpt: Her name was Emily Dunn, and over the weekend, a steady stream of friends and people who never knew her brought flowers, candles and photos of her to the site in the Castro where the young woman was killed Friday afternoon by a Muni driver. A grief-stricken friend, who I met Saturday, said Dunn, who was only 23, had moved to San Francisco from Atlanta a month ago and was just beginning a new life.

According to the San Francisco Examiner, Dunn was in the crosswalk and “had crossed the street about 95 percent of the way” when she was run over and killed around 2:30 p.m. by a Muni F-line shuttle turning from 18th Street onto Hartford. “The driver is shaken up by this,” a police spokesperson told the Chronicle, adding that “at this point there is no reason to believe he was impaired.”

In the Castro neighborhood where the collision occurred, the sadness was palpable. On Saturday and Sunday, some neighbors and visitors who didn’t know Dunn brought flowers and paid their respects to grieving friends who gathered at the site. One woman who works nearby told me her friend saw the aftermath, was very traumatized and began noticing “all the drivers who speed on 18th and are on their cell phones.”

SFMTA Chied Ed Reiskin, who went to the scene of the crash Friday, issued a “statement of condolences” on behalf of the agency:

Speaking for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency (SFMTA) and its 5,000 employees, I express our deepest sympathy to the family and friends of the pedestrian killed in the tragic accident this afternoon involving a Muni bus.  Our condolences go out to all concerned during this difficult time. The SFMTA will continue to work with the SFPD as we undertake all necessary investigations of this matter.

Elizabeth Stampe, the executive director of Walk San Francisco, called it a “real tragedy,” and said it points to the need for additional attention “to the priority of pedestrian safety in the city.”

“This could have been anyone hit and killed by a bus. I think this also points to the need for better training for Muni drivers, to watch out for vulnerable users of the streets,” she said. “We’re going to have more and more people walking and biking around our city, and we really need to figure out how to make it safer. We need a lot more fixes to our streets to make them safer.”

The SFMTA has not released any information about the driver, although we do have a request in for more information. We’ll update the story as we get more.

Update, 4:45 p.m : SFMTA spokesperson Paul Rose said the unidentified driver has been with Muni since January, and that he shouldn’t have been driving on Hartford.

“Our policy is to operate buses on streets that have regular assigned service. Hartford does not have scheduled service, and our policy is it should not operate on streets like that,” Rose said. The SFMTA did not immediately know the age of the driver, or where he resides.

Please click here to read the rest of this article and see the rest of the photographs and to read the comments.

And click here to learn about our current effort to keep this from ever happening again.

 March 3, 2015

A former San Francisco Municipal Railway bus driver who was facing charges of misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter for fatally striking a pedestrian in the city’s Castro District in August 2011 was found not guilty Friday.

Almost four years after the fatal crash, a San Francisco jury acquitted former Muni driver, Wallace Loggins, 40, in connection with the death of 23-year-old Emily Dunn, San Francisco District Attorney’s Office spokesman Alex Bastian said. …

Stuart Hanlon, Loggins’ attorney, said the collision was an accident and that jurors he spoke with felt the transit agency could have done more to prevent Dunn’s death.

Hanlon said an accident reconstruction expert, who testified at the trial, explained that Dunn was in a blind spot when she was struck.

According to Hanlon, a federal report that was published …encouraged bus companies to move the side mirrors up and train drivers on frontal blind spots, but Hanlon said Muni did not implement those changes. …

Hanlon said the accident might have been avoided if Muni changed the construction of its buses, moving up the side mirrors and making see-through walls at the front corners of the bus.

“Muni is responsible. They knew they needed to change the construction of the bus and train their drivers,” he said. …

Attorney Michael A. Kelly, who was one of the lawyers in a civil lawsuit filed against the city on behalf of Dunn’s parents, said the lawsuit was settled in 2014 and that Dunn’s family was awarded $2.85 million.

[Please click here to read the entire article.]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s