11 crossways on 17th St. that violate ADA

17th Street crosswalks violate the ADA from Castro Street to Church Street

LRV tracks trap wheelchair front tires and impede disabled folks in many ways. Some mobility impaired people are thrown by even small changes in the level of the sidewalk as occurs in certain track arrangements. People using canes and more elaborate mobility assistance devices can be delayed or trapped in the flange ways that run alongside the rails. On a foggy morning the steel rails will be slippery belts laid into the ash fault crosswalk.

The bottom line is that train tracks in urban crosswalks do constitute a serious issue and potential violation under the Americans with Disabilities Act. These pictures start at Castro Street & Market Street at the wheelchair ramp and continue down 17th Street all the way to Church Street examining each crosswalk impacted by these specific very controversial tracks.

Here’s a direct link to the document cited. It also addresses pedestrian islands and train stops in terms of width and clearance requirements. Good info.

Crosswalk # 1

Approaching the ramp from the South:


Putting the wheelchair ramp on an island in the middle of a set of tracks is a problematic plan from inception.


Crosswalk # 2

Here we will approach from the North, only having to cross one set of tracks which are completely plugged up just twenty yards away so no train could possibly ever use them. But they are present and must be crossed to get to the island.

vlcsnap-2016-06-29-19h43m15s239vlcsnap-2016-06-29-19h43m29s620vlcsnap-2016-06-29-19h43m49s557vlcsnap-2016-06-29-19h44m13s546vlcsnap-2016-06-29-19h45m04s380Crosswalk # 3

Proceeding East our next crosswalk is at the corner of 17th Street and Hartford St. where instead of a nice single track we have a set of switch tracks.


Crosswalk # 4

Our next intersection is 17th St. & Noe St. where three crosswalks are impeded by one track that is in service and several others that should have been removed decades ago. We will proceed through the walkways from the S.W. corner to the N.W. corner, continuing on to the N.E. corner and ending on the S.E. corner. While we are here it should be noted that this corner could be served with a single track for the F-Market streetcars to spin the block.


Crosswalk # 5

(Turn right to cross Noe St.)vlcsnap-2016-06-29-20h59m39s287vlcsnap-2016-06-29-20h59m53s854vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h00m06s854vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h00m24s138

Crosswalk # 6

(Turn right to cross 17th St. again)vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h01m22s989vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h01m33s953vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h01m48s708vlcsnap-2016-06-29-21h02m35s281


Crosswalk # 7

One block further to the East we come to the intersection of 17th and Sanchez Streets. The School is Sanchez Elementary School. This is a relatively simple case of two crosswalks that transverse 17th Street being impeded by two tracks that should not even be there.


Crosswalk # 8


Church Street Intersection

Our tour ends at 17th and Church Streets. A magnificent and deadly intersection this  massively overbuilt juncture was part of the detour route built in 1972 for the construction of Church Street Station and Castro Street Station.

This detour enabled the entire MUNI light rail system to run from Embarcadero up Market Street to Duboce Avenue (under the Mint) turning on Church Street to scoot over to 17th Street to head straight into the the Twin Peaks Tunnel at Eureka Street Station. It should have been disassembled back to the original Church Street North South tracks back in 1980 or at the very latest in 1997 when the Noe Street Terminal Loop opened for F-Market revenue service. But it is here now massively impeding access to three crosswalks.

Crosswalk # 9


Crosswalk # 10vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h18m45s473vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h19m06s215vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h19m20s640vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h19m34s484vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h19m54s765vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h20m14s870vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h20m22s388vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h20m49s254vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h21m05s839vlcsnap-2016-06-30-13h21m19s697


Crosswalk # 11vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h15m10s529vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h15m31s776vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h16m02s217vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h16m13s029vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h17m10s372vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h17m37s368vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h17m51s517vlcsnap-2016-06-30-17h18m41s353

What happens when bike tires get caught in the tracks? Check out this video to find out.

Curb Cuts and the ADA


Curb ramp construction meets the City’s obligations under federal and state accessibility statutes, regulations and policies to provide sidewalks and crosswalks that are readily and easily usable by persons with disabilities.
A fundamental provision of Title II of the Federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requires state and local governments to provide curb ramps. The U.S. Department of Justice (USDOJ) ADA Handbook states: “The legislative history of Title II of the ADA makes it clear that, under Title II, “local and state governments are required to provide curb cuts on public streets…(and)…the employment, transportation, and public accommodation sections of…[the ADA] would be meaningless if people who use wheelchairs were not afforded the opportunity to travel on and between streets.” ADA Section 35.151(e) establishes accessibility requirements for new construction and alterations, requiring all newly constructed and altered streets, roads, or highways must contain curb ramps or other sloped areas at any intersection having curbs or other barriers to entry from a street level pedestrian walkway. Paragraph (d)(2) clarifies the application of the general requirement for program accessibility to the provision of curb ramps at existing crosswalks.  (Source: http://www.sfcta.org/sites/default/files/content/Programming/propk/Annual_Calls/FY_2009-10/dpw%20curb%20ramps%20f.pdf)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s